She's got a new boy
  I guess that's good for her
  I know she'll have more in common with him
  Than with me anymore
    It's just the thought
  Of another arm around her shoulder
  Where my arm used to rest
  So comfortably
    She'll probably never be again
  As happy as I made her then
  But then I'll never really know for sure
  Will I?
    [Chorus]
  Nothing like the first time
  Fall in love so strong
  Please this is the last time
  I will ever sink so low
  My first time
    Well I can't sleep tonight
  I'm thinking about when you said yes
  That was the last time
  Either of us needed that much
    Got a new boy
  I could have picked
  Someone better for you
  Not that it matters much
  But we used to have the same taste
    But there's a first time for everything
  All the fine religion
  I guess I'm lucky for that
  But it just makes things harder for me now